23406 Agatha Avenue, Punta Gorda, FL, 33980

Address

23406 Agatha Avenue, PUNTA GORDA, FL

Listing Type

Active

Price

$ 697,900

Property Attributes

MLS#C7526628
TypeSingle Family
Listing Status Active
CountyCharlotte
CityPUNTA GORDA
AreaPort Charlotte
NeighborhoodPORT CHARLOTTE SEC 012
Zip33980
StyleCustom Victorian
Year Built2011
Taxes$ 4610
Price$ 697,900
Bedrooms3
Full Bathrooms2
Half Bathrooms2
Sqr Footage3031
Lot Size1.15 Acres

Data Source:

Stellar MLS

Property Description

Rarely does a property combine 1.15 acres across 5-contiguous lots w/ the architectural character, craftsmanship, & outdoor spaces found at this exceptional Port Charlotte estate. 1 mile from I-75, 1/3 mile from Publix, shops & restaurants, & directly across from Harold Avenue Regional Park, the setting offers privacy & everyday convenience. Hospitals, medical services, golf courses & beaches are all within a short drive. Significant major improvements provide exceptional peace of mind: NEW ROOF INSTALLED IN 2026, upgraded Trane XV20i 5-ton variable-speed, 3-zone HVAC system installed in 2023, & a 22kW Generac whole-house LP generator installed in 2017 w/ automatic transfer switch capable of powering the entire electrical system. Additional features include an LP tankless water heater, 2024 water softener, central vacuum, EV charging outlet & underground 500-gallon LP tank. Inspired by Victorian architecture w/ a refined farmhouse flair, the custom residence is defined by details rarely found in today's construction: multiple siding designs, stacked fascia, decorative scroll rafter ends, dimensional shingles w/ copper-penny open diverter valleys & drip edge, slate/stone entry steps, copper-penny roof accents, & an impressive, coffered entry ceiling w/ crown molding & beadboard. A wraparound style porch, IPE decking & breezeway w/ solid cypress beadboard ceilings extend the home's distinctive character. Inside, the craftsmanship continues with 10’ 1st-floor and 9’ 2nd-floor ceilings, vintage hand-finished ¾” solid oak flooring, oak staircase & window sills, oversized solid-core doors, oil-rubbed bronze hardware w/ vintage cut-glass knobs, solid-wood window jambs, custom cased openings & layered crown molding throughout, even the closets. The main level features an expansive foyer w/ sitting area & bay window, living & dining rooms, breakfast area, powder room, & custom kitchen w/ 1” thick cabinet doors, granite countertops, tile backsplash, 36” 6-burner gas cooktop, wood hood, double ovens, warming drawer & 2-pull-out dishwashers. The rear porch & breezeway feature IPE decking, cypress beadboard ceilings, granite counter w/ sink, cabinetry & LP gas grill connection. Upstairs, the primary suite features an angled bay-window sitting area & a beautifully appointed bath w/ marble shower, vintage clawfoot soaking tub, copper sinks, split vanities, stained glass & private water closet. 2 addn'l bedrooms & a well-designed hall bath complete the 2nd floor. The finished, air-conditioned attic adds multiple flexible spaces, custom cabinetry, a large clothing closet & half bath, ideal for an office, studio, hobby space or media room. The 5-lot grounds are a defining feature. 2nd lot is a private park-like retreat w/ mature oaks, multiple sitting areas, fire pit, & more than 250’ of meandering concrete walkways, plus a 50’ RV site with 50-amp electric, water & sewer. 3rd lot includes an 18x33 pool set 2’ into the ground, a 624-square-foot multi-level deck, a 12x24 framed shed matching the home, & a cleared area w/ plans for a proposed 1,276-sqft. 3-car garage w/ loft. 4th lot offers a cleared, park-like setting; 5th is cleared & prepared for a future home pad. Photos can showcase its beauty, but they cannot convey the character, craftsmanship & remarkable sense of place experienced when you walk these grounds & enter this home. Current homeowners’ insurance is $2,432.72 annually; declarations summary available upon request.

Elementary School	Middle School	High School
Kingsway Elementary School	Port Charlotte Middle Middle School	Port Charlotte High High School

Price History
7/1/2026	Listed $799,000
7/12/2026	3$777,000
7/16/2026	1$771,700
7/22/2026	10$697,000
7/27/2026	8$750,000
9/12/2026	7$697,900

General Features

Sewer	Public Sewer
Heating	Electric,Heat Pump
Cooling	Central Air,Zoned
Utilities	BB/HS Internet Available,Cable Connected,Electricity Connected,Fire Hydrant,Mini Sewer,Propane,Public,Sewer Connected,Water Connected
Possession	Close Of Escrow
Roof	Metal,Shingle
Appliances	Built-In Oven,Cooktop,Dishwasher,Disposal,Dryer,Exhaust Fan,Gas Water Heater,Microwave,Range Hood,Tankless Water Heater,Washer,Water Softener
Zoning	RSF3.5
Garage Spaces	2
Patio/Porch Features	Covered,Front Porch,Rear Porch
Architectural Style	Custom,Victorian
Pool Features	Above Ground,Deck,Vinyl
Security Features	Smoke Detector(s)
Construction Materials	Stone,Wood Siding
Pets Allowed	Yes
Year Built	2011
View	Park/Greenbelt,Trees/Woods
Levels	Three Or More
Property Subtype	Single Family Residence
Tax Year	2025
Ownership	Fee Simple
County	Charlotte
New Construction	false
Property Type	Residential
Attached Garage	false
Subdivision Name	PORT CHARLOTTE SEC 012
Facing Direction	South
Garage Y/N	true
Other Structures	Finished RV Port,Shed(s)
Total Rooms	14
Full Baths	2
Status	Active
Directions	From I75 exit 170, take Kings Highway south to Veterans Blvd. make right, then left on Peachland Blvd. then left on Loveland Blvd. then right on Agatha Ave. home on right side.
High School	Port Charlotte High
City	PUNTA GORDA
Senior Community Y/N	false
MLS Area	33980 - Port Charlotte
Lot Size Units	Acres
Lot Size Square Feet	50000
Carport Y/N	false
Listing Terms	Cash,Conventional,VA Loan
Elementary School	Kingsway
Land Lease Y/N	false
Tax Annual Amount	4610.37
Middle/Junior High School	Port Charlotte Middle
Additional Parcels Y/N	false
Lease Considered Y/N	true
Virtual Tour	https://tour.pinnaclerealestatemarketing.com/23406-Agatha-Ave/idx
Building Area Units	Square Feet
Living Area Units	Square Feet
Standard Status	Active
Occupancy Type	Owner
Tax Lot	4
Legal Description	PORT CHARLOTTE SEC 12 BLK 1589 LT 4 1168/1802 1180/363 2563/1869 PCH 012 1589 0005 PORT CHARLOTTE SEC 12 BLK 1589 LT 5 241/634 DC1160/514 1160/516 1462/199 2576/231 PCH 012 1589 0006 PORT CHARLOTTE SEC 12 BLK 1589 LT 6 408/537 823/17 1008/711 1158/505 1462/210 2576/231 PCH 012 1589 0008 PORT CHARLOTTE SEC12 BLK1589 LT 8 209/205 1695/1326 2376/616 CD2468/834 CD2468/835 CD2468/836 3703/580 TD4245/1841 4353/1958 PCH 012 1589 0007 PORT CHARLOTTE SEC12 BLK1589 LT 7 150/401 1131/212 DC4337/1149-PE 4337/1151
Minimum Lease	No Minimum
Water Access Y/N	false
Additional Rooms	Attic,Breakfast Room Separate,Formal Dining Room Separate,Formal Living Room Separate,Inside Utility
Water View Y/N	false
Flood Zone Code	X
In Law Suite YN	false
Flood Zone Code X	Yes

Interior Features

Interior Amenities	Ceiling Fan(s),Central Vacuum,Crown Molding,High Ceilings,PrimaryBedroom Upstairs,Stone Counters,Thermostat Attic Fan,Walk-In Closet(s),Window Treatments
Flooring	Hardwood
Furnished Y/N	Unfurnished
Total Stories	3
Air Conditioning Y/N	true
Heating Y/N	true
Window Features	Blinds,Double Pane Windows,Insulated Windows,Thermal Windows
Fireplace Y/N	false
Half Baths	2
Laundry Features	Gas Dryer Hookup,Laundry Room,Washer Hookup
Total Bedrooms	3
LivingAreaSource	Estimated
Total Baths	4

Exterior Features

Exterior Amenities	Fire Pit,Lighting,Private Yard,RV Hookup,Sidewalk,Storage
Vegetation	Mature Landscaping,Oak Trees,Trees/Landscaped
Fencing	Board,Fenced,Wood
Parking Features	Boat,Driveway,Electric Vehicle Charging Station(s),Garage Door Opener,Garage Faces Side,RV Parking,Workshop in Garage
Lot Features	In County,Landscaped,Level,Oversized Lot
Water Source	Public
Lot Size Area	1.1478
Foundation Details	Crawlspace,Pillar/Post/Pier
Spa	false
Building Area Total	3667
Lot Dimensions	400 x 125
Lot Size Acres	1.15
Road Surface Type	Asphalt
Private Pool	true
Waterfront Y/N	false
Covered Spaces	2
Number of Lots	3
Road Responsibility	Public Maintained Road